Buying guide

The best spicy ketchup, compared.

The best spicy ketchup depends on what you want the heat to taste like. Jalapeño ketchups (SpiceItUp!, Whataburger) give a fresh, green pepper warmth that works on everyday food. Tabasco-style ketchups are sharper and more vinegary. Habanero and ghost-pepper ketchups are about the burn. Here is how they compare, and how to pick.

SpiceItUp! jalapeño ketchup, Bloody Jalapeño mix and dusting salts

The short answer

For most people the best spicy ketchup is a jalapeño ketchup: enough heat to notice, a pepper flavor that tastes fresh rather than hot-sauce sour, and a thick tomato body that still works on fries and burgers. If you want a sharper, vinegar-forward kick, pick a Tabasco-style ketchup. If you want real burn, go habanero. SpiceItUp! has made jalapeño ketchup in Texas since 1995, in Medium and Hot, which is why Texans tend to measure the others against it.

Spicy ketchups, by type of heat

SpiceItUp! Jalapeño Ketchup (Medium and Hot)

Real jalapeños in a thick tomato ketchup, made in Corinth, Texas. Medium is an everyday kick; Hot is for people who keep hot sauce on the table. Flown on the Space Shuttle and a Scovie Award winner.

Whataburger Spicy Ketchup

The one most Texans know, with a jalapeño-style heat in a sweeter, fast-food ketchup. Sold in Texas grocery stores. Milder than SpiceItUp! Hot.

Tabasco-style spicy ketchups

Big-brand "hot" ketchups usually blend in a pepper sauce. The heat is sharper and more vinegary, and it shows up fast and fades fast.

Habanero and ghost-pepper ketchups

Small-batch hot ketchups for heat seekers. Fruity, intense, and easy to overdo on a plate of fries.

How to pick a spicy ketchup

Where the heat comes from
Real peppers (jalapeño, habanero) taste like the pepper. Pepper sauce or extract tastes mainly of heat and vinegar.
How hot
Jalapeño ketchups are mild to medium. Habanero ketchups are hot. Check for words like "extra hot" or "ghost".
Sweetness
Fast-food style ketchups run sweet; craft ketchups run tangier. Spicy ketchup for burgers can be sweeter; for eggs and seafood, less sweet is better.
Who makes it
Small Texas makers like SpiceItUp! cook in small batches; big brands add heat to an existing ketchup recipe.

What we use it on

Fries and onion rings first, then burgers, eggs, meatloaf glaze and sloppy joes. Our what to eat with jalapeño ketchup list has sixteen more, and the spicy ketchup guide goes deeper on Medium versus Hot.

Try the Texas one

Medium Jalapeño Ketchup 19oz

Medium Jalapeño Ketchup 19oz

$9.88

Details
Hot Jalapeño Ketchup 19oz

Hot Jalapeño Ketchup 19oz

$9.88

Details

Questions

What is the best spicy ketchup?

For everyday use, a jalapeño ketchup such as SpiceItUp! Medium or Hot: real pepper flavor with a mild-to-medium heat. Choose a habanero ketchup only if you want serious burn.

Is Whataburger spicy ketchup hot?

It is on the mild side, with a jalapeño-style flavor in a sweet ketchup. SpiceItUp! Medium is comparable; SpiceItUp! Hot is noticeably hotter.

What is the difference between spicy ketchup and jalapeño ketchup?

Spicy ketchup is any ketchup with added heat. Jalapeño ketchup gets that heat from jalapeño peppers, which give a fresh, green flavor rather than a vinegary hot-sauce bite.

Where can I buy SpiceItUp! jalapeño ketchup?

Online from this site, and in Texas stores listed on our where-to-buy page.